When it comes to choosing the perfect floor coverings for your home the choice can be difficult. For those looking for a cozy, defined space, wall-to-wall carpet or area rugs over hard flooring options are typically the go to. This leads many people to ask the question of which choice is better? The truth is, both area rugs and wall-to-wall carpeting have their pros, as well as their cons. Ultimately, it comes down to preference, style, price, and location. Read on to learn more about the differences between area rugs and wall-to-wall carpeting, their benefits, and drawbacks, as well as how to decide if either option could be right for you!
What Is an Area Rug?
An area rug is a piece of carpet like flooring, with bound edges, that does not extend from one side of the room to the other. It is also detached from the floor beneath it, allowing it to be easily moved or removed, without residue from glue being left behind. Area rugs are often used to define a specific space within a room and are typically made from woven fabrics, such as wool or synthetic fibers. They come available in many different shapes, sizes, and designs to accommodate any aesthetic. Area rugs can also offer intricate patterns and vibrant colors to add texture, comfort, and style to any room. For those who want to temporarily cover up an existing floor, bring warmth to a room, or define a space, area rugs can be a great solution.
What Is Wall-to-Wall Carpeting?
Wall-to-wall carpeting can be defined as a continuous piece of carpet that extends from one side of the room to the other and touches each wall. This type of floor covering is typically made from nylon, olefin, or wool fibers and comes in many different styles and colors to match any home’s décor. However, it is most commonly purchased in neutral tones that will work well with a range of décor and furniture. This flooring option is typically glued down and cannot be easily moved/removed if you tire of the color/style as it is a permanent floor covering.
What Are the Pros of Area Rugs?
There are many great reasons to consider using area rugs in your home. Consider them below:
1.) Versatility- Area rugs come in a variety of shapes, sizes, and patterns, allowing you to customize your space however you’d like. If you’re looking to cover up an existing floor or add a pop of color to a room, an area rug may be the perfect choice. Additionally, since they are detachable, you can easily change out your area rug as often as you’d like.
2.) Cost- Area rugs tend to be more cost effective than wall-to-wall carpeting, making them a great option for those who are on a budget.
3.) Easy to maintain and clean- Since area rugs are not permanently attached to the floor, they can be easily removed and taken outside for cleaning. In the same vein, since they are affordable, and can easily be removed, if your rug becomes damaged or you tire of its appearance, you can easily replace it with something new.
What Are the Cons of Area Rugs?
Just as there are many great reasons to choose an area rug, all good things come with some drawbacks. Being aware of the pros, as well as the cons, can help you to make the right decision for your home. Ponder if the pros are worth the cons below:
1.) Slipping and sliding- Since area rugs are not glued fast to the floor, they may be prone to moving or sliding. While there are ways to counteract this, area rugs pose a fall risk if not properly secured. Thus, if you’re using an area rug in a high traffic area, it is important to make sure it is properly secured or consider using a non-slip pad underneath to prevent accidents.
2.) Durability- While area rugs can last for many years with proper care, they are not as durable as wall-to-wall carpeting. Depending on the area rug’s material and quality, it may require more frequent cleaning or replacing than wall-to-wall carpeting.
3.) Lack Uniformity- Area rugs typically come in patterns and bright colors, rather than neutrals. This can make it difficult to create flow and uniformity within your home.
What Are the Pros of Wall-to-Wall Carpeting?
Wall-to-wall carpeting also comes with its fair share of benefits. They will be discussed further below:
1.) Noise Reduction- Wall-to-wall carpeting is great for those who are looking to reduce noise in their home. This type of floor covering can help muffle sound, making it ideal for living areas or bedrooms where peace and quiet is desired.
2.) Comfort- Wall-to-wall carpeting is a great choice for those who want to add an extra layer of comfort and warmth to their home. The plush surface of this type of floor covering will feel amazing under your bare feet!
3.) Durability- Wall-to-wall carpeting is made to last, making it perfect for high traffic areas, such as living rooms and hallways. This type of floor covering can easily withstand the daily wear and tear of a busy home, making it a wise long-term investment.
What Are the Cons of Wall-To-Wall Carpeting?
Understanding the flaws of wall-to-wall carpeting is an important part of making an informed decision. Consider how these cons would affect you, should you choose to go with wall-to-wall carpeting in your home.
1.) Cleaning- Wall-to-wall carpeting is not as easy to clean as area rugs since it can’t be removed for cleaning or easily replaced when damaged. This can become a hassle over time, especially if you have pets or small children making frequent messes.
2.) Cost- Installing wall-to-wall carpeting can be quite expensive and typically requires professional installation.
3.) Limited options – While there are a variety of styles and colors to choose from, your design options and colors are typically more limited with wall-to-wall carpeting than with area rugs.
4.) Gas Emissions- New carpet releases chemical by products into the air for weeks to months after installation.
5.) Wear pattern- Since wall-to-wall carpet will be more heavily utilized in certain areas than others, higher traffic areas may show obvious wear when compared with lower traffic areas of the room.
Which Option Is Right for You?
When it comes to choosing between area rugs and wall-to-wall carpeting, there is no right or wrong answer. It all depends on your budget, style preference, and home needs. If you’re looking for a softer and warmer feel, wall-to-wall carpeting may be the better choice. However, if you’re looking for more design options and easier maintenance, area rugs could be the way to go. After considering the pros and cons of each option, could an area rug or wall-to-wall carpeting be the right flooring option for your home?